‘Judge Me Not’ Recap & Ending Explained: What Happens Between Jay And Larry Steele?

You know, some people have this incredible inner strength, like they’ve got unique wiring that helps them handle whatever life decides to throw their way. They might go through a lot, to the point where it seems like everything is falling apart, but there’s something deep within them—a stubborn determination to never give up—that remains unshaken. Zelma Jay Johnson, commonly known as Jay, is truly one of those extraordinary individuals, and her journey in the series Judge Me Not is nothing short of fascinating. The series delves into the rollercoaster of Jay’s life as she navigates through broken relationships, battles her traumatic past, and tenaciously pursues her ultimate goal of becoming a judge.


Spoilers Ahead 

What Is Jay’s Approach To Handling Her Life As A Judge?

Judge Zelma Jay Johnson’s life takes an unexpected turn as she embarks on a new chapter in her career. At just 31 years old, she’s about to make history by becoming the first woman of color to hold a prestigious position as a judge, Inspired by the real-life experiences of renowned Judge Lynn Toler, the series Judge Me Not delves into the intricacies of Jay’s life as she navigates multiple hurdles. Initially, everything seems smooth sailing for Jay as she settles into her new role. Her adeptness in handling clients and reading body language proves vital in the courtroom, contributing to her selection as a judge. However, beneath the surface, things are not as they seem. The weight of this groundbreaking achievement and the responsibility it carries start to weigh heavily on her shoulders.


As Judge Jay takes on challenging cases involving sensitive matters such as racism and domestic violence, she realizes the immense gravity of her decisions and their impact on people’s lives. The weight of justice becomes tangible, and she must tread carefully through the intricate web of emotions and legal complexities. Adding to her tribulations, Jay faces constant conflicts with Judge Ruth Spangler at the workplace. These clashes threaten to weaken her resolve, but Jay is no pushover. Her indomitable spirit and determination shine through as she stands her ground, refusing to back down before anyone. Overall, Jay’s character is quite a fascinating study, offering a compelling insight into the multitude of deep-rooted factors that drive her decisions. While some may wonder why she chooses to stay at her current law firm when other prestigious opportunities beckon, it becomes apparent that her personal history and family dynamics play a significant role in shaping her choices.

Growing up in a family that appears perfect from the outside but harbors painful secrets within, Jay’s life has been marked by traumatic experiences, especially those involving her father’s struggles with mental illness. One pivotal moment from her childhood stands out when she witnessed her father Richard’s violent outburst, shoving her mother, Yvonne, through a window. This traumatic event left an indelible mark on Jay’s psyche, shaping her perception of safety and stability. Interestingly, the law firm where Jay currently works becomes a refuge for her and her family. It’s not just a workplace; it symbolizes a safe haven where they can escape her father’s unpredictable behavior and find some semblance of security. This emotional attachment to the firm goes beyond professional ambitions; it becomes deeply intertwined with her personal well-being.


Why Is There A Lack Of Compatibility Between Jay And Daryl?

The dynamics between Jay and Daryl seem to be a rollercoaster ride, with highs and lows characterizing their relationship. Daryl has shown remarkable understanding and support for Jay, consistently motivating and encouraging her to adhere to her prescribed medications for depression and anxiety. He genuinely cares for her well-being and wants the best for her. However, Jay’s tendency to frequently change doctors has become a significant source of tension between them. This behavior has created a rift in her mind as she struggles to fully rely on and trust medical professionals. Instead, she finds herself increasingly dependent on her subconscious self to navigate her mental health issues, which can be an unhealthy coping mechanism. On the other hand, Jay’s ongoing struggle with alcohol exacerbates the challenges she faces. It seems that a family history of mental health-related issues exists, and this could be a contributing factor to her own struggles.

While her brother seems unaffected, Jay can’t help but attribute her issues—possibly bipolar disorder—to her father, Richard. The dynamics between Jay and Daryl are undoubtedly complex, and their relationship faces challenges due to Jay’s ongoing struggles. Daryl is a caring and empathetic partner who understands that Jay is going through a lot, and he acknowledges the difficulties she is facing. He misses her presence in their relationship, and this feeling is entirely understandable given the circumstances. However, Daryl’s constant   complaints about Jay’s absence can become overwhelming for her. While he may be expressing genuine concern, Jay might be burdened by the notion that she does not measure up to his expectations or the relationship’s demands. She is going through a lot of personal challenges, and his constant reminders of her absence might exacerbate her feelings of guilt or inadequacy.


In the heat of an argument, Jay expresses her frustration to Daryl, telling him that he tends to make every problem about himself. It’s essential to note that Jay’s statement doesn’t necessarily mean that Daryl is selfish but rather highlights how his approach to addressing their issues might be unintentionally contributing to the strain between them. Jay’s struggles lie in the circumstances she is facing and her reluctance or stubbornness to seek the right treatment for her mental health challenges. This creates a rift between her and Daryl because he likely wants to see her happy and well, but she might be hesitant to take the necessary steps toward healing.

The relationship between Jay and Daryl becomes increasingly complex as they grapple with their conflicting needs and desires. Daryl’s frustration arises from the feeling that Jay puts her family before their relationship, which leads to their drifting apart. He wants her to focus more on their bond and prioritize their connection. On the other hand, Jay’s deep sense of responsibility towards her family, especially her mother, due to her father’s medical history is understandable. She has firsthand experience with the challenges and terror her family has endured, and it’s natural for her to feel compelled to be there for her mother during difficult times.

Daryl’s desire for more attention and commitment from Jay is valid; it’s crucial to recognize the significance of Jay’s role within her family. Her upbringing and personal experiences have shaped her understanding of family responsibility, which she takes very seriously. These differences in opinion and core values create tension that sets them apart and alters their respective needs within the relationship. Their contrasting perspectives and basic understanding of what a relationship entails become significant hurdles they must navigate. It’s essential for both of them to communicate openly and honestly about their feelings and needs, finding a way to strike a balance between family obligations and maintaining a healthy relationship with Daryl.

What Does Jay Find Out While Working On The Steele Family Case?

In the midst of resolving various minor cases, Jay’s attention is finally captured by the compelling Steele family case. Siblings Larry and Lily Steele find themselves locked in a bitter dispute, with Lily accusing Larry of stealing her scarves and figurines. While Lily lacks concrete evidence to support her claims, she can’t shake the feeling that something is amiss whenever Larry returns the scarves. As Jay delves deeper into the case, she is surprised by Lily’s meticulous documentation of the dates when Larry took and returned the scarves. Although Jay is skilled at reading body language, she can’t glean any definitive information from the siblings’ interactions. Unbeknownst to Jay, a shocking revelation awaits her. Behind the seemingly innocuous disputes over scarves lies a dark and horrifying truth. Larry has been inflicting harm on Lily, using manipulation and control to suppress her attempts to expose his hidden secret. This secret lies hidden in his basement, where he commits heinous acts, taking the lives of young women.


Intrigued by Lily Steele’s claims regarding Larry’s car, Jay decides to investigate further to ascertain if there’s any truth to her suspicions. When she personally examines the car, she makes a crucial discovery: a strand of black hair in the trunk. This unexpected finding immediately catches Jay’s attention, raising red flags about Larry’s true intentions. Although Jay’s instincts tell her that something is terribly wrong, she realizes that this strand of hair alone may not be enough to build a solid case against Larry. She doesn’t have concrete proof linking him to any criminal activity, and jumping to conclusions could jeopardize the legal process and the pursuit of justice.

At this pivotal moment, Jay faces a challenging decision. She knows that dismissing the case could potentially allow a dangerous individual to escape the consequences of his actions. However, she also understands that proceeding without substantial evidence could lead to an acquittal, allowing Larry to continue his harmful behavior. So, Jay chooses to pretend that she didn’t notice anything out of the ordinary and dismisses the case. While this might seem like an unconventional move for a judge, Jay’s strategic decision is motivated by her desire to build a stronger case against Larry. She wants to gather more evidence discreetly to continue her investigation as she starts connecting the missing girls’ cases with Lily Steele’s claims.


‘Judge Me Not’ Ending Explained: What Happens Between Jay And Larry Steele?

Judge Me Not takes a thrilling turn as Jay finds herself dealing with myriad challenges and a rift in her relationship with Daryl due to his connections with the women of High Bar. The revelation of Daryl’s possible betrayal leaves Jay stunned and distrustful. Overwhelmed by these emotional upheavals, she loses track of her cases and stops taking her medications, leading her to give into her alter ego, which is an alarming sign of her mental state. Despite these struggles, Jay’s determination to pursue justice remains unwavering, especially in Larry’s case. Her attention to detail, even amidst personal turmoil, leads her to a startling discovery: the dates of the missing women’s disappearance correlate with the dates when Larry took Lily’s scarves. This revelation serves as a crucial piece of evidence, linking Larry to the potential crimes.

Before Jay can act on this discovery, Larry attacks her and breaks into her house, holding her captive. However, Jay remains composed, realizing that Larry derives satisfaction from inflicting fear and pain on his victims, especially women with authority over men. Her understanding of Larry’s hatred towards women and his twisted sense of righteousness becomes pivotal in her efforts to survive and expose his crimes. Jay discovers incriminating evidence on Larry’s camera, proof she needs to bring him to justice. While trying to escape and trap him, she’s constantly worried about Lily’s safety, as Larry has yet to reveal any information about her.


As the tension escalates, Jay realizes that Larry’s patience has reached its limits, and he intends to kill her. But in a daring act of courage, she manages to break free and escape to another room. Just when the situation seems dire, Daryl arrives at Jay’s place, concerned by her lack of response to calls from friends and family. In the climactic ending, a scuffle ensues between Daryl and Larry, and Jay finds herself forced to defend herself. She takes decisive action, using a hammer to protect herself, and tragically, it results in Larry’s death. As the truth unravels, Jay realizes that Larry had been stalking her for days, and his previous focus on Judge Ruth Spangler had shifted to her when he felt she was closing in on him.

Judge Me Not hints at Larry’s troubled past, possibly suggesting a tumultuous and abusive childhood that may have shaped his violent tendencies. While it doesn’t delve into his backstory extensively, his behavior towards Lily and his need for control imply deep-seated issues that influence his actions. Despite her traumatic ordeal, Jay emerges victorious in putting an end to Larry’s atrocities, sparing other potential victims from his malevolence. Her experience in dealing with this harrowing case becomes a catalyst for her self-discovery and understanding of her true purpose. Finding solace in Daryl’s arms, Jay realizes the importance of taking care of herself to become the protector she aspires to be for others. While Judge Me Not offers a compelling narrative and intriguing exploration of Lynn Toler’s life, it may fall short in certain areas due to a lack of detailed characterization and background. A more in-depth examination of certain plot points and characters could have potentially strengthened the impact of the series.


Raschi Acharya
Raschi Acharya
Raschi Acharya is a Mass Media graduate and she is currently working and living in Mumbai. From a very young age, Raschi was heavily interested in reading and writing. She prefers to write everything that her mind nurtures her to do as shaping up her imagination is her forte!

Latest articles